Cinnamon Toast Crunch co*cktail Recipe - These Old Cookbooks (2024)

January 31, 2020November 9, 2023

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Want to taste cinnamon toast crunch without the cereal? You can make a cinnamon toast crunch flavored drink with ingredients you have on hand. Here’s how to make the Fireball cinnamon toast crunch co*cktail.

What do you get when you combine Baileys Irish Cream, Fireball Cinnamon Whisky and milk? The result is a Cinnamon Toast Crunch co*cktail that will go down smooth as an evening nightcap.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch co*cktail Recipe

Sometimes we are inspired by our readers. Here’s a shout out to Amie who suggested that we modify our Baileys Milk recipe by adding some Fireball Cinnamon Whisky. The result is creamy deliciousness with spicy cinnamon flavor. Thanks Amie!

If you love red hots or cinnamon stick candies, then this drink is for you.

It starts with our basic Baileys Milk recipe which is one part Baileys Traditional Irish Cream mixed with one part milk. The addition of Fireball gives the co*cktail a nice cinnamon taste which truly tastes like a bowl of cinnamon toast crunch.

You know what Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal is, right? It’s a kid’s cereal (or husband’s cereal in my family) that has a sugary, cinnamon coating on every bite. There’s no doubt that it’s delicious, but I am not particularly convinced on the nutritious part.

Easy Fireball Drink Ingredient List

• Milk, any type
• Fireball Cinnamon Whisky
• Baileys Irish Cream

How to Make a Cinnamon Toast Crunch Drink

Step By Step Instructions

1. Add ice to a glass or co*cktail shaker.
2. Mix (or shake) together milk, Baileys Irish Cream and Fireball Whiskey.
3. Stir and drink.
4. Try dusting with a mixture of cinnamon and sugar (or nutmeg) on top or around the rim. Or, top with whipped cream.
5. Sip and enjoy your fireball and milk drink recipe.

For the full recipe steps and ingredient amounts for how to drink a Baileys Irish Cream, scroll to the bottom of this post.

Recipe FAQs

• 3 Ingredient co*cktails are the best, and this Cinnamon Toast Crunch Drink fits that bill.
• Use whatever type of milk you prefer – whole, 2%, skim, oat milk, almond milk, half and half or heavy cream (if you are going for decadence).
• Baileys Irish Cream is a alcoholic whiskey with flavors of cocoa and and cream.
• Swap Baileys for Rumchata, if desired.
• Fireball Cinnamon Whisky is an alcohol that is intensely sweet and full of cinnamon flavor.
• This is a beefed up version of our favorite Baileys Milk recipe. We also have a Chocolate Baileys Recipe.
• To keep your co*cktail cold longer, try using large ice cubes. You can find these special ice cube trays on Amazon. Check out our Amazon Store to see an option, as well as our favorite kitchen items.
• To make a Cinnamon Toast Crunch shot, mix equal parts Fireball Whisky and Baileys Irish Cream in a shot glass.
• Start with the booze in the fridge for a colder drink.

What to mix with Fireball Whisky?

Looking for an easy mixer for Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey? Here’s a list of ten easy mixers for Fireball Whisky.

1. co*ke or Diet co*ke
2. Iced or Hot Coffee
3. Apple Juice or Apple Cider (cold or hot)
4. Milk or Chocolate Milk
5. Ginger Ale
6. Orange or Pineapple Juice
7. Sprite
8. Cranberry or Grape Juice
9. Hot Tea or Iced Tea
10. Ginger Beer
11. Cream soda
12. Hot chocolate

How to Make a Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot?

It’s so easy to make a Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot. Mix equal parts Fireball Whisky and Baileys Irish Cream. The result is delicious and deadly. Watch out, these go down way too easy.

What does fireball and milk taste like?

Fireball and milk is the start of a Cinnamon Toast Crunch co*cktail. Add some Irish Whisky for a dessert in a glass!

Our Favorite co*cktail Recipes

We love a good co*cktail and have several on our site AND our blogging friends have some good drink recipes too! Here are a few of our favorites:

Peanut Butter and Jelly co*cktail

Dirty White Russian co*cktail

Lake Lemonade co*cktail

Bay Breeze for a Crowd

Cranberry Moscow Mule

Sneaky Pete Drink

Baileys Strawberries and Cream Milkshake

Gingerbread Baileys co*cktail